This chapter continues my reflections on the three archetypal perspectives of ‘self-development’, ‘self-surrender’ and ‘self-discovery’ that have been providing us with a framework for a big-picture overview of the Buddhist approach to Enlightenment and spiritual practice. As it is a continuation of the line of enquiry of my last chapter, I am currently calling it simply ‘Self-Power, Other-Power, and Beyond – Part 2’. While the chapter does stand on its own to some extent, I recommend that you read my previous chapter first – it can be accessed by clicking here.
This chapter continues to use the overview of Buddhism from an archetypal point of view, that was presented by one of Sangharakshita’s students, Dharmachari Subhuti, in a talk that he gave in 2003. Because it is loosely-based on the three ‘yānas’ of Hinayāna, Mahayāna, and Vajrayāna – pointing out the way in which we can see these re-capitulated in the spiritual development process of individual Western practitioners – it would probably be incorrect to say that these are Subhuti’s ideas. I am nevertheless very deeply grateful to him for his initiative in presenting this fresh and much-needed conceptualisation, and for his recognition that these three approaches should be thought of as archetypal perspectives.
Extending considerably beyond the starting point for discussion that Subhuti provided, I have been presenting a personal examination of the range of problems and possible Dharmic misunderstandings that can arise when the characteristically ‘Eastern’ archetypal psychology of Buddhism is expressed within the collective unconscious mindset of the modern West. This exploration is also, necessarily, an investigation of the particular archetypal predisposition and current collective challenges of what we might call the ‘Western ego’ – so it is in part an investigation of the egoic mind as it has emerged with particular collective characteristics, within the context of the very particular historical conditions of the West.
Sadly, I found myself giving up on the Buddhist tradition at the end of my twenties, having lived a full-time Buddhist lifestyle for many years. While I had a very deep experience of Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha – the Three Jewels of Buddhism – and for many years had been seized by a passionate commitment, the Buddhism that I experienced at that time, was full of deep incongruities. Indeed, I found aspects of its practice in a Western context to be deeply un-ethical and psychologically crude. My rejection of these incongruities, led me to lose all connection with Buddhism for more than three decades – even though aspects of its wisdom continued to serve as foundational points of reference for me.
My discovery of Dharmachari Subhuti’s ‘Three Myths’ model, in about 2019, initiated a profound healing process for me – a difficult healing process accompanied by grief, as a flood of insights that had previously eluded me, arose. This three-fold framework provided me with a whole new way of understanding spirituality, and a whole new way of understanding the experiences of Buddhism that had so profoundly impacted me in my twenties. My intensive process of learning within Western Buddhism back in the 1980s, was somewhat unusual. It seems that it was my fate – my karma, as we say in Buddhism – to see what can go wrong when the heroic idealism of what Subhuti called the ‘development’, or ‘self-development’ perspective is over-emphasised, and when the other two perspectives are not adequately integrated into Dharma practice and Sangha culture.
Because I studied archetypal psychology concurrently with Buddhism in my twenties, I already had many insights in the form of archetypal reflections on the limitations of identifying Buddhism with the heroic ‘self-power’ perspective. It was not until I came across Subhuti’s model however, and more recently David Brazier’s advocacy of an ‘other-power’ Buddhism based on Pure Land Buddhism (Jodo Shinshu), that I found validation for my instinct that Western Buddhist practice naturally evolves beyond the heroic and may even take on an entirely different and opposite ‘other-power’ frame of reference.
So, this chapter continues my archetypal psychological observations on the way this universal dichotomy of ‘self-power’ and ‘other-power’ plays out in individuals; in groups and societies; and in the processes of history. I shall continue to move between reflections on our individual process as Western meditation practitioners, our group processes as members of Western Buddhist Sanghas, and my reflections on the archetypal processes that have shaped Western history and culture. While I want to continue to validate the neglected ‘other-power’ perspective, I hope to also continue providing an outline of Buddhism’s third perspective, which reconciles the dichotomy of ‘self-power’ and ‘other-power’ – Subhuti’s ‘self-discovery’ perspective, which have been calling Vajrayāna.
This chapter is a work-in-progress. I welcome comments, if anyone wants to write to me via the contact form.
My overall aim with this book is to explore the four foundational elements of Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’ (Integration, Positive Emotion, Spiritual Death, and Spiritual Rebirth) in the light of Buddhism’s traditional trikāya model of mind. In this endeavour, I have found Dharmachari Subhuti’s ‘Three Myths’ model to be powerfully explanatory – an outline of the three very different archetypal perspectives that we find combined in different ways, and emphasised to different degrees, in Buddhist tradition. In this chapter, I shall be continuing to seek the three-fold synthesis of these three perspectives, and continuing to highlight the dangers of practicing these approaches in isolation – especially the dangers of the heroic ‘self-development’ approach, which corresponds to the default perspective of the Western ego, and therefore is very often practiced in a one-sided way that excludes the other two perspectives.
In Part 1 of this long essay, as part of an analysis of the key elements of the default ‘heroic’ (self-development) perspective of the Western mind, I pointed out that the Hero archetype is more than just the archetype of the egoic will. It also provides the archetypal basis for our compulsion to be on the side of the ‘good’ in the judgmental dynamic of good-and-evil that is always at play within the construction of personal and social identity. Even more important, in the light of our three-fold model of ‘self-development’, ‘self-surrender’ and ‘self-discovery’, and our Buddhist aspiration towards true individuality, the heroic mindset tends to lead to a darkly dysfunctional expression of our archetypal need for ‘self-surrender’. It seems that if human beings cannot find a positive expression for this archetypal need for authentic spiritual surrender to the ‘other-power’ of the dharmic reality, then this universal impulse will instead find expression in willing surrender of individuality through emersion in the group – which of course leaves us very vulnerable to psychological manipulation by the powerful.
While a conscious and positive ‘self-surrender’ and recognition of the true Other Power of the dharmic reality leads to a deepening of ethics and wisdom; the unconscious ‘self-surrender’ to the ‘other-power’ of the group, is a sacrifice of our discernment and our intelligence, to the group’s values and beliefs. Far from being a route to personal responsibility, ethics and spiritual self-transcendence; the dark reality of the archetype of the heroic, is such that even in the context of genuine Buddhist idealism, it will usually lead to a loss of individuality. The heroic mind’s tendency is to disintegrate our experience into polarities of consciousness and unconscious – and to divide our world by creating sharp dichotomies of ‘good’ and ‘bad’; ‘right’ and ‘wrong’; wanted and not-wanted; valued and de-valued, etc. Needless to say, our deep unconsciousness of the fundamentally erroneous and judgemental way in which the heroic mind describes and give conceptual definition to our world; when combined with our compulsion to lose ourselves in group processes, serves to undermine any true ethical sensibility – even in the most well-intentioned Western Buddhist.
I shall be getting into the cognitive-perceptual details of this loss of ethics in my next chapter. For now, let me just add that it is through the ‘form-creating’ rūpa skandha that the heroic mind ‘forms’ its distorted descriptions of reality. In the Buddha’s use of the term, the rūpa skandha denotes the reifying, concretising process by which the conceptualising, narrative-forming intellectual mind constructs a reality rather than allowing our actual objective reality to ‘be as it is’. In the context of the egoic mind, the rūpa skandha believes itself to be merely observing reality and describing it objectively, when in fact it is weaving an illusion. Significantly, this thinking function of the mind, describes both self and world as having ‘form’ – and being fixed and separate – when in reality everything is process, and both self and world are open systems. So the ‘form’ of things is an illusion, and what form they have, is only the ’empty’ form provided by the archetypes and systemic processes.
So, while we might imagine that the egoic will is at the core of our moral agency and is the prime driver of the processes of spiritual integration that we are seeking; in reality it simultaneously creates internal conflict and disintegration, and undermines our ethical sensibilities by creating psychological Shadow – our cognitive-perceptual blind-spots. This is why it is so important that Western Buddhist practitioners find forms of expression of the ‘self-surrender’, or ‘other-power’ archetype that are deeply authentic and true. We must each find a real personal response to the objective realities of the eternal dharmakāya and the archetypal samboghakāya. It may help you to know that we do not need to be able to distinguish these two subtle realities from each other. Indeed it is best, in my view, to see them as inseparable – since the unknowable dharmakāya and the visionary and bodily-felt sambhogakāya, are the un-manifest and the manifest aspects of a single dharmic reality. And thankfully that dharmic reality is ever-present, and available to us in every moment of Mindfulness.
We are all familiar with the idea of peer-pressure in groups. In regard to the heroic perspective and the heroic mode of consciousness, there is a similar social psychological dynamic that is so deeply inherent in the heroic, and so deeply inherent in the egoic mind, that it usually functions completely unconsciously. There may sometimes have been a superficial dynamic that we might call peer-pressure operating in those who attended Hitler’s Nuremberg rallies in the 1920s and 1930s, but more fundamentally, what history witnessed was a dimension of the archetype of the heroic. What was seen was a mass assertion of the egoic will through an experience of mass-consciousness, and a joyful and willing surrender to that experience – a willing surrender of individual rationality and discernment through immersion in the tribal consciousness of German nationalism. While the reparations that were imposed at the Treaty of Versailles in June 1919, had been calculated to break the German spirit, the Nazis, in reaction to the violence of that punishing impulse, created a compelling heroic vision of a vigorous Germany with a renewed sense of national destiny, and filled with an instinctual vitality and purpose – a vision which was explicitly framed in the language of heroic self-surrender and self-transcendence.
Self-transcendence is a concept that Buddhists use too easily and without reflection – seemingly unaware that processes of self-transcendence can be both positive and negative. It is often used in place of the term ‘self-development’ that I have used for the first of Subhuti’s ‘Three Myths’. Since we are seeking to understand the ‘back’ or Shadow of the ‘self-transcendence’, or ‘self-development’ ‘myth’, it is useful to reflect that the Nazis advocated, and indeed experienced, a form of self-transcendence – but not in good way. It is because of this association that I avoid, and would like to strongly discourage, exchanging Subhuti’s terms in that way. Reflecting on this opposite form of ‘self-transcendence’, a very similar expression of the same archetype, and of the same heroic impulse to surrender to the ‘other-power’ of the group, may help us to recognise the very different self-transcendence via the Middle Way that the Buddha was advocating – and may help us to understand why a narrowly heroic approach to Buddhism should be regarded as very problematic, or even as antithetical to the more comprehensive and balanced three-fold view that we need to be cultivating.
The heroic ‘group’ that I am talking about here is a collective manifestation of the heroic ego – both are socially constructed. The egoic self and the group in which it is inseparably embedded are expressions of the same archetypal pattern. This is why the archetypal imagery of the Six Realms in Buddhist cosmology, provide such compelling images of the way in which the egoic mind finds collective expression – and in that collective expression manifests the egoic tendencies (kleshas) in extreme ways. The group, on one side, and the non-individual ego, on the other, are a reflection of each other in the social psychological and individual psychological realms. As with the egoic mind, the group’s potential for evil is not at first apparent. Indeed, in the context of the heroic, the ability to surrender our ethically discerning heart and our intellectual clarity to group processes, can very easily appear to be a virtue. This dynamic of negative self-transcendence and negative self-surrender to the ‘other-power’ of the group, can very easily be present in a Sangha, no less than it was in Nazi Germany. The manifestation of the archetype is a matter of degree, the archetype playing out is the same.
The great Hannah Arendt, reporting on the Adolf Eichmann trial in her 1963 book, Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil, gave a brilliant psychological analysis of the paradoxical way in which individuals in a society seized by the hero archetype lose their individuality – giving up any sense of personal ethical responsibility. Eichmann, who was charged, by Hitler, with the job of administrating the ‘Final Solution’ to the Nazi’s ‘Jewish problem’, was an intelligent and well-educated man. We fail to understand the nature of evil if we imagine him as a mad person with an insane hatred of the Jews – he was just a rather ordinary and efficient bureaucratic servant of the German state, who was able to use his intelligent rationalising mind to transcend individual ethical responsibility. Studying Eichmann’s testimony, Arendt gave a wonderfully clear description of the way in which a denial of responsibility, and a denial of the humanity of the identified enemy gets woven into the language of the heroic group. Evil was indeed well-described, by Arendt, as banal – so commonplace and deeply woven into the fabric of life that it goes unnoticed if we are not practicing that profound vigilance, which the Buddha called apramāda.
Properly understood, the archetypal principle of Sangha in Buddhism provides a counterpoint to the phenomenon of the heroic group. A Sangha is a Buddhist group that aspires to go beyond functioning merely as a social group or as a religious institution, but a community of beings who are at various stages on the path to Enlightenment. So, it is a group in which the individual practitioners, by endeavouring to practice the true ‘self-surrender’ of samādhi, or meditative-receptivity, begin to express a true spiritual autonomy of body, speech and mind – no longer socially surrendered to group norms, but guided by an ‘other-power’ relationship with the dharmic reality; relating to self and world with Mindfulness; and engaged in a true ‘Going For Refuge’.
The archetypes of Buddha and Sangha – of Enlightenment and true spiritual community – are an inseparable pair. The path to Enlightenment involves a process of learning to function as a true individual within a true Sangha – and the Dharma is our guide to both. It is very significant therefore, that we understand Sangha deeply, and understand that the Sangha archetype is profoundly undermined by the heroic ‘self-development’ perspective, and requires the cultivation of a true ‘other-power’ spiritual culture. So, Sangha is profound spiritual reality – it requires the collective practice of true ‘self-surrender’, if it is to find embodiment in this nirmānakāya world. To think of a Sangha as a ‘Buddhist group’ is to completely miss what Sangha is. I hope in the course of the book to be able to show that Sangha is a sublime ideal – and one that requires not just our heroic idealism but our ‘self-surrender’ to the dharmic reality. And ultimately, it requires a culture of ‘self-discovery’ – a culture of ‘self-enquiry’ dyad practices and of resting ‘as’ Consciousness.
From the point of view of Buddhist wisdom, there are no evil individuals – only archetypal and systemic processes that lead to evil outcomes through the egoic problem of what we can call identification or personalisation. In Western culture, Hitler has become a favourite enemy image for conflation with individuals who have been targeted for regime change by the Western military alliances – by people whose job it is to provoke Shadow projection, and manipulate populations by evoking the archetype of the heroic fight of good against evil. Hitler is nevertheless, a useful figure to reflect on – a person who can perhaps help us to understand the pathology of the heroic. Hitler was an unusual leader in that he was an introvert, but like other leaders he had a very keen intuitive sense of the power of the heroic. He had a particularly deep understanding of the suffering and thwarted aspirations within the soul of the German people – it was as if he instinctively knew their psychological inner landscape – and most importantly, he had a particular instinct for the Warrior Hero archetype in German culture, and understood how to harness the power of that archetype.
So, Hitler almost certainly recognised that the Hero, when awakened in the collective, creates a force that subjectively appears noble, but objectively has a capacity for violence and inhumanity, and for ignorant submission, woven into it inherently. If he was evil, it was in his conscious use of his intuitive understanding of the nature of the heroic to gain personal power over the German people and to inspire them to violence – initially against those within Germany who saw what he was doing, and subsequently against Germany’s external enemies. He instinctively understood how to provoke a mass identification with the heroic, so that the energy of the German population would be at his service, while dissolving the individuality of each individual German man and woman into their national identity. With this knowledge he was able to mobilise a heroic idealism that was simultaneously deeply inhumane – easily crushing all political opposition, eliminating German democracy and establishing himself as the absolute leader. He used the language of nobility, effectiveness, and heroism to place Germany in the hands of its most violent, heartless, and unconscious individuals – people who were ruthlessly effective in their pursuit of Hitler’s goals; people for whom an absence of empathy was regarded as a source of strength.
If we have a foundational knowledge of archetypal psychology, and are well-informed about history, we cannot approach the heroic without deep ambivalence. I shall be attempting a more detailed cognitive-perceptual analysis of why this is, in my next chapter, which is on the Buddha’s systemic model of the self – the five skandhas. This form of analysis, and self-enquiry into the nature of ’emptiness’ (shunyatā), is characteristic of the ‘self-discovery’ level of practice that I have been calling Vajrayāna. One of the main problems of the heroic (‘self-development’) approach to Buddhist practice is that it, in effect affirms the illusion of fixed and separate self, and leaves no room for the Buddha’s foundational insight that the self is ’empty’ of self-nature – just a coming together of cognitive-perceptual processes to create the appearance of a self. Because the heroic is so deeply incongruous with this more ultimately true way of thinking, the ‘self-development’ perspective will always create a one-sided and incongruous mode of consciousness. I find it curious when I see Buddhists presenting the Dharma as if it were just a more refined and spiritually idealistic form of the heroic. Because the heroic is the default perspective of the egoic mind, it simply cannot be crudely harnessed to the service of the good in this way.
The Hero is the archetype of that narrow and inherently partial mode of consciousness that is the basis of our suffering. As Western Buddhists we may talk of using power in the service of love, but in the context of the exclusive ‘self-development’ orientation, the power mode is always our default, and will always be predominant – unless we are willing to integrate a deep and authentic form of real ‘other-power’ Buddhism into our practice. For me, the integration of ‘self-power’ and ‘other-power’ that we need, is to be found in the three-fold perspective – the Middle Way perspective that I have been calling Vajrayāna. The Vajrayāna form of Mindfulness practice, in which we repeatedly take short moments to rest ‘as’ Consciousness and release our identification with the minds cognitive-perceptual contents, offers our best hope of liberation from our cognitive-perceptual blindness. Our attachment to the heroic ‘self-development’ perspective is understandable given the egoic mind’s propensities, but it’s limitations as a basis for spiritual development are tragically underestimated and, in my opinion, not sufficiently understood by Buddhists.


