Mandala of Love
  • Home
  • Meditation
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • ‘Meditation’ April 2017
      • A ‘Mandala of Love’ approach to Meditation
      • Self-Inquiry – Familiarising ourselves with Consciousness
      • The Content of the Mind is Not Important
      • Non-Duality – Buddha, Jesus, and Plato
      • Objectivity – Meditation and Thinking
    • ‘Meditation’ May-Jun 2017
      • René Descartes’ Error
      • Mindfulness – The Buddha’s ‘Remembering’ practice
      • Egoic consciousness – Divided against itself
      • Nurturing an Authentic Self
      • The Four Brahmavihāras – Four Attitudes of Consciousness
      • Mettā – Consciousness as Loving-Kindness
      • The Ethical and Relational Nature of Consciousness
      • The Brahmavihāras – the Soul’s Moral Compass
    • ‘Meditation’ Jul-Aug 2017
      • Upekṣā – Equanimity – Touching the Cosmic Stillness
      • Resting the Mental Body in the Field of Consciousness
      • The Mirror of Consciousness and the Mirror of Narcissism
      • The Hara – the Mysterious Second Chakra
      • The ‘Hell Realms’ – Inner Victims and Inner Persecutors
      • Muditā – Sympathetic Joy – A Sense of Wonder
    • ‘Meditation’ Sept-Oct 2017
      • Sympathetic Joy – an Attitude and an Energetic State
      • Zen and the Art of Human Life
      • Zazen – Just Sitting – Resting as Consciousness
      • Plato’s Cave Revisited
      • The Yin and Yang of Embodied Consciousness
    • ‘Meditation’ Nov-Dec 2017
      • Feeling – The Discernment of Goodness, Value and Beauty
      • Mettā – Living as Love and Contentment
      • Mettā – Healing the Egoic Shadow of Love
      • The Preta Realm – Deprivation, Despair, and Addiction
    • ‘Meditation’ Jan-Apr 2018
      • Flowing with the Currents of Feeling – Psychological Parts
      • Mettā – Being Unconditionally Present with Feeling
      • Empathy and Self-Empathy – Communication and Self-Enquiry
      • Feminine and Masculine – Energy and Presence
    • ‘Meditation’ May-Aug 2018
      • The Yin and Yang of Love and Compassion
      • The Asura Realm – Intuition and the Egoic Will
      • The Mandala and the Stupa
      • The Somatic Anatomy of the Energy Bodies
      • The Mandala of the Four Brahmavihāras
    • ‘Meditation’ Sept-Oct 2018
      • Consciousness, Meditation and the Four Qualia
      • The Beneficial Life Energy of Needs
      • Life Energies of Presence and Connection
    • ‘Meditation’ Nov-Dec 2018
      • Compassion and the All-Accomplishing Wisdom
    • ‘Meditation’ 2019 Jan-Oct
      • The Dharmadhātu Wisdom
      • Akashadhateshvari – Luminous Space
    • ‘Book Chapter’ Articles
      • William Blake’s ‘Jerusalem’
      • Introduction to the Mandala of Love book blog
      • The Cross and the Mandala
      • Carl Jung’s Psychology of the Archetypes
      • The Mandala as the Landscape of the Soul
      • Buddhas and Bodhisattvas – Archetypes of Consciousness
      • Jung’s Phenomenology of the Soul
      • Egoic Consciousness and its Shadow
  • 5 Wisdoms
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Skandhas Intro
      • The Dharmadhātu Wisdom
      • Akashadhateshvari / White Tara – Luminous Space
      • The Five Skandhas – Dakini Wisdom
      • The Five Skandhas – the Cognitive-Perceptual Components
    • Rūpa Skandha
      • Part 1: Thinking and Wisdom
      • Part 2: The Mirror-Like Wisdom
      • Part 3: The Body
    • Vedanā Skandha
    • Samjñā Skandha
    • Samskāras Skandha
    • Vijñāna Skandha
  • 10 Buddhas
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Padmasambhava’s Inspiration-Prayer
    • 10 Buddhas – Introduction
      • Part 1: Three Yānas / Three Myths
      • Part 2: Ten Dharmic Principles
      • Part 3: Resting as Consciousness
      • Part 4: Integration and Positive Emotion
    • 10 Buddhas – Integration
      • Part 5: Pandaravārsini
      • Part 6: Vajrasattva-Akshobya
      • Part 7: The Somatic Body-Mind
      • Part 8: Māmaki
    • 10 Buddhas – Positive Emotion
    • 10 Buddhas – Spiritual Death
    • 10 Buddhas – Spiritual Rebirth
  • Buddhism
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Images of Samādhi
      • The Trikāya
    • A System of Practice
      • 2. The Middle Way
      • 3. ‘Three Myths’ – Part 1
      • 4. ‘Three Myths’ – Part 2
    • Hui Neng and the Mirror-Like Wisdom – A Zen Story
    • ‘Meditation’ Series Overview
      • A Mandala Framework for Meditation and Self-Enquiry
      • Resting as Consciousness
    • Padmasambhava’s Inspiration-Prayer
  • NVC/Focusing
    • Buddhism and Focusing
      • Part 1 – Eugene Gendlin’s ‘Clear Space’ and the Brahmavihāras
    • Nonviolent Communication (NVC) – Mandala Wisdom
    • Mandala Innerwork and NVC Self-Empathy
    • NVC/Focusing-related articles in other categories
      • Summaries of these articles
      • Feeling – The Discernment of Goodness, Value and Beauty
      • Empathy and Self-Empathy – Communication and Self-Enquiry
      • The Asura Realm – Intuition and the Egoic Will
  • Jung/MBTI
  • Home
  • Meditation
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • ‘Meditation’ April 2017
      • A ‘Mandala of Love’ approach to Meditation
      • Self-Inquiry – Familiarising ourselves with Consciousness
      • The Content of the Mind is Not Important
      • Non-Duality – Buddha, Jesus, and Plato
      • Objectivity – Meditation and Thinking
    • ‘Meditation’ May-Jun 2017
      • René Descartes’ Error
      • Mindfulness – The Buddha’s ‘Remembering’ practice
      • Egoic consciousness – Divided against itself
      • Nurturing an Authentic Self
      • The Four Brahmavihāras – Four Attitudes of Consciousness
      • Mettā – Consciousness as Loving-Kindness
      • The Ethical and Relational Nature of Consciousness
      • The Brahmavihāras – the Soul’s Moral Compass
    • ‘Meditation’ Jul-Aug 2017
      • Upekṣā – Equanimity – Touching the Cosmic Stillness
      • Resting the Mental Body in the Field of Consciousness
      • The Mirror of Consciousness and the Mirror of Narcissism
      • The Hara – the Mysterious Second Chakra
      • The ‘Hell Realms’ – Inner Victims and Inner Persecutors
      • Muditā – Sympathetic Joy – A Sense of Wonder
    • ‘Meditation’ Sept-Oct 2017
      • Sympathetic Joy – an Attitude and an Energetic State
      • Zen and the Art of Human Life
      • Zazen – Just Sitting – Resting as Consciousness
      • Plato’s Cave Revisited
      • The Yin and Yang of Embodied Consciousness
    • ‘Meditation’ Nov-Dec 2017
      • Feeling – The Discernment of Goodness, Value and Beauty
      • Mettā – Living as Love and Contentment
      • Mettā – Healing the Egoic Shadow of Love
      • The Preta Realm – Deprivation, Despair, and Addiction
    • ‘Meditation’ Jan-Apr 2018
      • Flowing with the Currents of Feeling – Psychological Parts
      • Mettā – Being Unconditionally Present with Feeling
      • Empathy and Self-Empathy – Communication and Self-Enquiry
      • Feminine and Masculine – Energy and Presence
    • ‘Meditation’ May-Aug 2018
      • The Yin and Yang of Love and Compassion
      • The Asura Realm – Intuition and the Egoic Will
      • The Mandala and the Stupa
      • The Somatic Anatomy of the Energy Bodies
      • The Mandala of the Four Brahmavihāras
    • ‘Meditation’ Sept-Oct 2018
      • Consciousness, Meditation and the Four Qualia
      • The Beneficial Life Energy of Needs
      • Life Energies of Presence and Connection
    • ‘Meditation’ Nov-Dec 2018
      • Compassion and the All-Accomplishing Wisdom
    • ‘Meditation’ 2019 Jan-Oct
      • The Dharmadhātu Wisdom
      • Akashadhateshvari – Luminous Space
    • ‘Book Chapter’ Articles
      • William Blake’s ‘Jerusalem’
      • Introduction to the Mandala of Love book blog
      • The Cross and the Mandala
      • Carl Jung’s Psychology of the Archetypes
      • The Mandala as the Landscape of the Soul
      • Buddhas and Bodhisattvas – Archetypes of Consciousness
      • Jung’s Phenomenology of the Soul
      • Egoic Consciousness and its Shadow
  • 5 Wisdoms
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Skandhas Intro
      • The Dharmadhātu Wisdom
      • Akashadhateshvari / White Tara – Luminous Space
      • The Five Skandhas – Dakini Wisdom
      • The Five Skandhas – the Cognitive-Perceptual Components
    • Rūpa Skandha
      • Part 1: Thinking and Wisdom
      • Part 2: The Mirror-Like Wisdom
      • Part 3: The Body
    • Vedanā Skandha
    • Samjñā Skandha
    • Samskāras Skandha
    • Vijñāna Skandha
  • 10 Buddhas
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Padmasambhava’s Inspiration-Prayer
    • 10 Buddhas – Introduction
      • Part 1: Three Yānas / Three Myths
      • Part 2: Ten Dharmic Principles
      • Part 3: Resting as Consciousness
      • Part 4: Integration and Positive Emotion
    • 10 Buddhas – Integration
      • Part 5: Pandaravārsini
      • Part 6: Vajrasattva-Akshobya
      • Part 7: The Somatic Body-Mind
      • Part 8: Māmaki
    • 10 Buddhas – Positive Emotion
    • 10 Buddhas – Spiritual Death
    • 10 Buddhas – Spiritual Rebirth
  • Buddhism
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Images of Samādhi
      • The Trikāya
    • A System of Practice
      • 2. The Middle Way
      • 3. ‘Three Myths’ – Part 1
      • 4. ‘Three Myths’ – Part 2
    • Hui Neng and the Mirror-Like Wisdom – A Zen Story
    • ‘Meditation’ Series Overview
      • A Mandala Framework for Meditation and Self-Enquiry
      • Resting as Consciousness
    • Padmasambhava’s Inspiration-Prayer
  • NVC/Focusing
    • Buddhism and Focusing
      • Part 1 – Eugene Gendlin’s ‘Clear Space’ and the Brahmavihāras
    • Nonviolent Communication (NVC) – Mandala Wisdom
    • Mandala Innerwork and NVC Self-Empathy
    • NVC/Focusing-related articles in other categories
      • Summaries of these articles
      • Feeling – The Discernment of Goodness, Value and Beauty
      • Empathy and Self-Empathy – Communication and Self-Enquiry
      • The Asura Realm – Intuition and the Egoic Will
  • Jung/MBTI
Mandala of Love
  • Home
  • Meditation
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • ‘Meditation’ April 2017
      • A ‘Mandala of Love’ approach to Meditation
      • Self-Inquiry – Familiarising ourselves with Consciousness
      • The Content of the Mind is Not Important
      • Non-Duality – Buddha, Jesus, and Plato
      • Objectivity – Meditation and Thinking
    • ‘Meditation’ May-Jun 2017
      • René Descartes’ Error
      • Mindfulness – The Buddha’s ‘Remembering’ practice
      • Egoic consciousness – Divided against itself
      • Nurturing an Authentic Self
      • The Four Brahmavihāras – Four Attitudes of Consciousness
      • Mettā – Consciousness as Loving-Kindness
      • The Ethical and Relational Nature of Consciousness
      • The Brahmavihāras – the Soul’s Moral Compass
    • ‘Meditation’ Jul-Aug 2017
      • Upekṣā – Equanimity – Touching the Cosmic Stillness
      • Resting the Mental Body in the Field of Consciousness
      • The Mirror of Consciousness and the Mirror of Narcissism
      • The Hara – the Mysterious Second Chakra
      • The ‘Hell Realms’ – Inner Victims and Inner Persecutors
      • Muditā – Sympathetic Joy – A Sense of Wonder
    • ‘Meditation’ Sept-Oct 2017
      • Sympathetic Joy – an Attitude and an Energetic State
      • Zen and the Art of Human Life
      • Zazen – Just Sitting – Resting as Consciousness
      • Plato’s Cave Revisited
      • The Yin and Yang of Embodied Consciousness
    • ‘Meditation’ Nov-Dec 2017
      • Feeling – The Discernment of Goodness, Value and Beauty
      • Mettā – Living as Love and Contentment
      • Mettā – Healing the Egoic Shadow of Love
      • The Preta Realm – Deprivation, Despair, and Addiction
    • ‘Meditation’ Jan-Apr 2018
      • Flowing with the Currents of Feeling – Psychological Parts
      • Mettā – Being Unconditionally Present with Feeling
      • Empathy and Self-Empathy – Communication and Self-Enquiry
      • Feminine and Masculine – Energy and Presence
    • ‘Meditation’ May-Aug 2018
      • The Yin and Yang of Love and Compassion
      • The Asura Realm – Intuition and the Egoic Will
      • The Mandala and the Stupa
      • The Somatic Anatomy of the Energy Bodies
      • The Mandala of the Four Brahmavihāras
    • ‘Meditation’ Sept-Oct 2018
      • Consciousness, Meditation and the Four Qualia
      • The Beneficial Life Energy of Needs
      • Life Energies of Presence and Connection
    • ‘Meditation’ Nov-Dec 2018
      • Compassion and the All-Accomplishing Wisdom
    • ‘Meditation’ 2019 Jan-Oct
      • The Dharmadhātu Wisdom
      • Akashadhateshvari – Luminous Space
    • ‘Book Chapter’ Articles
      • William Blake’s ‘Jerusalem’
      • Introduction to the Mandala of Love book blog
      • The Cross and the Mandala
      • Carl Jung’s Psychology of the Archetypes
      • The Mandala as the Landscape of the Soul
      • Buddhas and Bodhisattvas – Archetypes of Consciousness
      • Jung’s Phenomenology of the Soul
      • Egoic Consciousness and its Shadow
  • 5 Wisdoms
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Skandhas Intro
      • The Dharmadhātu Wisdom
      • Akashadhateshvari / White Tara – Luminous Space
      • The Five Skandhas – Dakini Wisdom
      • The Five Skandhas – the Cognitive-Perceptual Components
    • Rūpa Skandha
      • Part 1: Thinking and Wisdom
      • Part 2: The Mirror-Like Wisdom
      • Part 3: The Body
    • Vedanā Skandha
    • Samjñā Skandha
    • Samskāras Skandha
    • Vijñāna Skandha
  • 10 Buddhas
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Padmasambhava’s Inspiration-Prayer
    • 10 Buddhas – Introduction
      • Part 1: Three Yānas / Three Myths
      • Part 2: Ten Dharmic Principles
      • Part 3: Resting as Consciousness
      • Part 4: Integration and Positive Emotion
    • 10 Buddhas – Integration
      • Part 5: Pandaravārsini
      • Part 6: Vajrasattva-Akshobya
      • Part 7: The Somatic Body-Mind
      • Part 8: Māmaki
    • 10 Buddhas – Positive Emotion
    • 10 Buddhas – Spiritual Death
    • 10 Buddhas – Spiritual Rebirth
  • Buddhism
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Images of Samādhi
      • The Trikāya
    • A System of Practice
      • 2. The Middle Way
      • 3. ‘Three Myths’ – Part 1
      • 4. ‘Three Myths’ – Part 2
    • Hui Neng and the Mirror-Like Wisdom – A Zen Story
    • ‘Meditation’ Series Overview
      • A Mandala Framework for Meditation and Self-Enquiry
      • Resting as Consciousness
    • Padmasambhava’s Inspiration-Prayer
  • NVC/Focusing
    • Buddhism and Focusing
      • Part 1 – Eugene Gendlin’s ‘Clear Space’ and the Brahmavihāras
    • Nonviolent Communication (NVC) – Mandala Wisdom
    • Mandala Innerwork and NVC Self-Empathy
    • NVC/Focusing-related articles in other categories
      • Summaries of these articles
      • Feeling – The Discernment of Goodness, Value and Beauty
      • Empathy and Self-Empathy – Communication and Self-Enquiry
      • The Asura Realm – Intuition and the Egoic Will
  • Jung/MBTI
  • Home
  • Meditation
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • ‘Meditation’ April 2017
      • A ‘Mandala of Love’ approach to Meditation
      • Self-Inquiry – Familiarising ourselves with Consciousness
      • The Content of the Mind is Not Important
      • Non-Duality – Buddha, Jesus, and Plato
      • Objectivity – Meditation and Thinking
    • ‘Meditation’ May-Jun 2017
      • René Descartes’ Error
      • Mindfulness – The Buddha’s ‘Remembering’ practice
      • Egoic consciousness – Divided against itself
      • Nurturing an Authentic Self
      • The Four Brahmavihāras – Four Attitudes of Consciousness
      • Mettā – Consciousness as Loving-Kindness
      • The Ethical and Relational Nature of Consciousness
      • The Brahmavihāras – the Soul’s Moral Compass
    • ‘Meditation’ Jul-Aug 2017
      • Upekṣā – Equanimity – Touching the Cosmic Stillness
      • Resting the Mental Body in the Field of Consciousness
      • The Mirror of Consciousness and the Mirror of Narcissism
      • The Hara – the Mysterious Second Chakra
      • The ‘Hell Realms’ – Inner Victims and Inner Persecutors
      • Muditā – Sympathetic Joy – A Sense of Wonder
    • ‘Meditation’ Sept-Oct 2017
      • Sympathetic Joy – an Attitude and an Energetic State
      • Zen and the Art of Human Life
      • Zazen – Just Sitting – Resting as Consciousness
      • Plato’s Cave Revisited
      • The Yin and Yang of Embodied Consciousness
    • ‘Meditation’ Nov-Dec 2017
      • Feeling – The Discernment of Goodness, Value and Beauty
      • Mettā – Living as Love and Contentment
      • Mettā – Healing the Egoic Shadow of Love
      • The Preta Realm – Deprivation, Despair, and Addiction
    • ‘Meditation’ Jan-Apr 2018
      • Flowing with the Currents of Feeling – Psychological Parts
      • Mettā – Being Unconditionally Present with Feeling
      • Empathy and Self-Empathy – Communication and Self-Enquiry
      • Feminine and Masculine – Energy and Presence
    • ‘Meditation’ May-Aug 2018
      • The Yin and Yang of Love and Compassion
      • The Asura Realm – Intuition and the Egoic Will
      • The Mandala and the Stupa
      • The Somatic Anatomy of the Energy Bodies
      • The Mandala of the Four Brahmavihāras
    • ‘Meditation’ Sept-Oct 2018
      • Consciousness, Meditation and the Four Qualia
      • The Beneficial Life Energy of Needs
      • Life Energies of Presence and Connection
    • ‘Meditation’ Nov-Dec 2018
      • Compassion and the All-Accomplishing Wisdom
    • ‘Meditation’ 2019 Jan-Oct
      • The Dharmadhātu Wisdom
      • Akashadhateshvari – Luminous Space
    • ‘Book Chapter’ Articles
      • William Blake’s ‘Jerusalem’
      • Introduction to the Mandala of Love book blog
      • The Cross and the Mandala
      • Carl Jung’s Psychology of the Archetypes
      • The Mandala as the Landscape of the Soul
      • Buddhas and Bodhisattvas – Archetypes of Consciousness
      • Jung’s Phenomenology of the Soul
      • Egoic Consciousness and its Shadow
  • 5 Wisdoms
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Skandhas Intro
      • The Dharmadhātu Wisdom
      • Akashadhateshvari / White Tara – Luminous Space
      • The Five Skandhas – Dakini Wisdom
      • The Five Skandhas – the Cognitive-Perceptual Components
    • Rūpa Skandha
      • Part 1: Thinking and Wisdom
      • Part 2: The Mirror-Like Wisdom
      • Part 3: The Body
    • Vedanā Skandha
    • Samjñā Skandha
    • Samskāras Skandha
    • Vijñāna Skandha
  • 10 Buddhas
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Padmasambhava’s Inspiration-Prayer
    • 10 Buddhas – Introduction
      • Part 1: Three Yānas / Three Myths
      • Part 2: Ten Dharmic Principles
      • Part 3: Resting as Consciousness
      • Part 4: Integration and Positive Emotion
    • 10 Buddhas – Integration
      • Part 5: Pandaravārsini
      • Part 6: Vajrasattva-Akshobya
      • Part 7: The Somatic Body-Mind
      • Part 8: Māmaki
    • 10 Buddhas – Positive Emotion
    • 10 Buddhas – Spiritual Death
    • 10 Buddhas – Spiritual Rebirth
  • Buddhism
    • Summaries of these Articles
    • Images of Samādhi
      • The Trikāya
    • A System of Practice
      • 2. The Middle Way
      • 3. ‘Three Myths’ – Part 1
      • 4. ‘Three Myths’ – Part 2
    • Hui Neng and the Mirror-Like Wisdom – A Zen Story
    • ‘Meditation’ Series Overview
      • A Mandala Framework for Meditation and Self-Enquiry
      • Resting as Consciousness
    • Padmasambhava’s Inspiration-Prayer
  • NVC/Focusing
    • Buddhism and Focusing
      • Part 1 – Eugene Gendlin’s ‘Clear Space’ and the Brahmavihāras
    • Nonviolent Communication (NVC) – Mandala Wisdom
    • Mandala Innerwork and NVC Self-Empathy
    • NVC/Focusing-related articles in other categories
      • Summaries of these articles
      • Feeling – The Discernment of Goodness, Value and Beauty
      • Empathy and Self-Empathy – Communication and Self-Enquiry
      • The Asura Realm – Intuition and the Egoic Will
  • Jung/MBTI

Monthly Archive: January 2024

3. Self-Power, Other-Power, and Beyond – Part 1

 

 

This is one the introductory chapters of a rather ambitious book that I am writing that is provisionally entitled ‘Mandala of Love – A Tantric Buddhist model of Mind and Meditation Practice’. In the previous chapter, which you can read here, I introduce two important Dharmic frameworks – the Trikāya Doctrine and Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’. I recommend that you read that chapter first. I find the trikāya to be a fundamental framework for understanding Buddhism, and find that it provides a useful doorway into an understanding of the Buddha’s notion of a Middle Way – an idea that we need to be able to understand deeply and broadly, as both a philosophical principle and an approach to practice.     

I want to emphasise, as I did in my preface to the previous article, that the approach to understanding Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’ that I am offering here, is a very personal one – I might even say that it is a maverick view. While I may share my thoughts with some conviction, I am not asserting a definitive interpretation. I only want to contribute to the discussion.

This chapter is, in large part, a response to the powerfully explanatory ‘Three Myths’ model (‘self-development’, ‘self-surrender’ and ‘self-discovery’) that was presented by Sangharakshita’s student, Dharmachari Subhuti, in 2003. Not a ‘model’ as such, this is a conceptual framework that many who know the history of the Buddhist tradition will be familiar with. I find it very engaging because I believe that it illuminates important universal truths. Indeed, this conceptualisation – a fresh naming of the three main strands of philosophy and practice within the Buddhist tradition – presents Buddhism as containing three nested archetypal perspectives. Like many others, I have adapted the model to some extent, as I have made use of it to explain the way I have come to think about Dharma practice. Once again, my presentation of this conceptual framework should be regarded only as a personal view, and as a stimulus to reflection and discussion – and certainly not as definitive in any way.

This chapter contains a lot of reflections that may seem very personal to my particular process of learning within Buddhism, which was perhaps somewhat unusual. It does however contain a lot of challenging insights that seem to me to be universal and generally applicable. Although these understandings have been difficult to adequately articulate, they seem to me, when I look at what is currently happening in our world, to be extremely urgent and important. I welcome comments, if anyone wants to write to me via the contact form.

 

In this chapter, I shall be continuing to introduce the Trikāya Doctrine and Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’. I shall also be making use of Dharmachari Subhuti’s ‘Three Myths’ model, which I introduced at the end of my last chapter, as a way of exploring the dichotomy of ‘self-power’ and ‘other-power’ in Dharma practice. In his ‘Three Myths’ talk (2003) and article (2004), Subhuti set out to draw our attention to the way Dharma practice, for Western practitioners, tends to progress in a way that begins with a ‘self-power’ emphasis (an archetypal perspective that has been called the ‘self-development’ myth); and then moves to incorporate an ‘other-power’ dimension (an archetypal perspective that has been called the ‘self-surrender’ myth); and then moves to an approach that transcends the apparent dichotomy of the two previous stages (an archetypal perspective that has been called the ‘self-discovery’ myth).

The ‘Three Myths’ framework gives us a way of understanding the three yānas – Hinayāna; Mahayāna; Vajrayāna –  the three phases of the historical evolution of Buddhism. Even more significantly however, it shows us how the corresponding shifts of apparent emphasis within Buddhist philosophy are reflected in our own evolving practice. Following Subhuti’s archetypal approach to this enquiry, I also want to reflect further on the need for those of us who aspire to be more conscious, to gain a capacity for this sort of archetypal psychological reflection. By this, I do not mean only an awareness of the archetypal Buddhas of the sambhogakāya. We also need to be keenly aware of the corresponding ‘negative’ archetypal imagery of the Buddhist tradition’s ‘Six Realms’ – the archetypes that show us the egoic mind’s dysfunction. This is a theme that I shall be covering in more detail in later chapters. In this two-part essay, my focus shall be on an exploration of Subhuti’s three archetypal perspectives.

This three-fold archetypal analysis generates a vast amount of reflection for me. I have a lot of criticism to share in regard to the ‘self-development’ perspective – a perspective that becomes very problematic when it is practiced in isolation, especially if it also being practiced in an extreme way – and I shall be highlighting the great need for us to aspire to a three-fold synthesis of the three archetypal perspectives. The adoption, as our sole frame of reference for understanding Buddhism, of the philosophically narrow and one-sided ‘self-development’ view can be disastrous. Because the necessary Middle Way balance to the ‘self-development’ view is found in the ‘self-surrender’ view, we need to get experientially clear as to what that means. This is why I prefer to use the term ‘other-power’ in connection with the ‘self-surrender’ perspective. We need to be very clear what we are surrendering to. We need to be clear that we are surrendering to the objectively existing dharmic ‘other-power’ of the sambhogakāya and dharmakāya – not simply to a constructed ideal that the heroic ego has imagined, or to the authority of those who represent the Buddhist tradition.

Presenting a three-fold view that offers the potential for a reconciliation of the dichotomy of ‘self-power’ and ‘other-power’, I shall be offering a perspective on the Vajrayāna. Tibetan Vajrayāna is culturally extraordinarily rich and complex – so much so, that Western practitioners can sometimes miss what is most essential and most valuable in the tradition. Hopefully cutting through some of that cultural complexity, I shall be seeking that essence of Vajrayāna that was present, I believe, at various times, in Gautama Buddha’s teachings – most notably in his characterisation of his teaching as a ‘Middle Way’.

I shall be presenting Vajrayāna as a mode of practice that aspires to a transcendence of ‘self-power’ / ‘other-power’ dichotomy – a mode of practice that incorporates, but also transcends, both the heroic idealism of ‘self-power’ (the ‘self-development’ myth), and the devotional-receptive ‘other-power’ perspective (the ‘self-surrender’ myth). For me, the term ‘self-discovery’ does not begin to encompass the subtlety and profundity of the Vajrayāna perspective, but a conceptual label that would do it justice would be hard to find – so I hope that my provisional use of the term Vajrayāna for the three-fold view, will itself serve us as an adequate conceptual label. This third way, or Middle Way, that I am, perhaps rather confusingly, calling Vajrayāna, is found in every part of the Buddhist tradition. Wherever a true ‘other-power’ Buddhism is practiced, there exists the possibility of this experiential reconciliation of ‘self-power’ and ‘other-power’; of nirmānakāya and dharmakāya; of conditioned and unconditioned; and of samsara and nirvāna – and it is that reconciliatory view, and that reconciliatory approach to practice, that I am calling Vajrayāna.

The Buddhist path looks very different at the end than it does at the beginning. Indeed, it is common for Dharma practitioners to look back after decades of practice, and realise that their previous years of passionate engagement with the Dharma were informed by various egoic delusions – various misunderstandings or partial truths that had been constraining their progress. We may even realise that, in our idealistic striving, we were sometimes striving for the wrong things. We may become aware that we have created conflict for ourselves. We may even have to accept that we had, a times, put our trust in people who were ultimately not worthy of the degree of trust that we placed in them.

We may find that an un-discerning trust in the reliability of the guidance of our teachers is held up to us as a virtue. The Buddhas own teaching in this regard was in stark contrast. He urged us to regard all teachings, including his own (and interpretations of his own teachings) as provisional – as hypotheses to be tested in our experience. Every aspect of spiritual teaching, from our basic meditation practices and ethical precepts to the highest metaphysical teachings, must be subjected to this testing process. Indeed the spiritual life can be seen as a progressive process in which we gradually refine our understanding through the rigour of this testing process. The teaching frameworks of various strands of the Buddhist tradition are nirmānakāya phenomena – they are imperfect and provisional. It is only by deep contemplation and scrutiny, and by seeking to realise the sambhogakāya and dharmakāya realities behind the teachings, that we can discern the truth.

The whole Buddhist tradition has engaged in this testing and refinement process over the twenty-five centuries of its history. Indeed, it has been through several major ‘life-review processes’ collectively, and has sometimes recognised that its earlier conceptualisations were inadequate or incomplete. The Buddhist tradition’s development through three cultural and historical phases – Hinayāna, Mahayāna and Vajrayāna – may be seen both as a consequence of a natural self-critical and reflective process, and as a natural collective evolution in which the archetypal realities of the sambhogakāya and dharmakāya were being articulated more and more clearly over time in the concrete nirmānakāya world of the recorded Buddhist teachings and associated culture.

So, via processes that involved both rigorous introverted thinking and an ongoing conceptual clarification of the traditions teachings, on one side; and direct visionary revelation of the sambhogakāya level of mind, on the other, the tradition underwent a process of improvement and integration. These processes are now entering a whole new phase of consolidation, as centuries of traditional teachings are analysed by Westerners, and are becoming integrated with compatible currents within Western culture and Western psychological thought.

Continue reading

January 14, 2024

2. The Trikāya Doctrine – A ‘Middle Way’ Model of Mind

 

 

Writing about the Dharma is, for me, a contemplative and exploratory process. I see myself as engaged in a ‘self-discovery’ process, in which I am engaged in deep ‘self-enquiry’ in order to reveal the actual experiential truths behind the Dharmic formulations. While I also try to be faithful to the tradition’s accumulation of commentaries on the Dharma that I have been taught, the greater imperative for me is to be true to this contemplative process and to be true to my own knowing – something that the Buddha always emphasised. So, it is not sufficient from my point of view, to reduce the Dharma down to conceptual definitions that have only a superficial logic. Rather, my aim is to reflect deeply on these formulations and to unpack them and expand them, and investigate their deeper meaning and implications. So, as often happens, this article became complex and more seemingly ambitious in the course of my writing of it. Indeed, I have now re-edited it as one of the introductory chapters of a book whose provisional title is ‘Mandala of Love – A Tantric Buddhist Psychology of Mind and Meditation Practice’.

So, this piece of writing will be one of the introductory chapters in a series of about twelve chapters, which take Sangharakshita’s original four-fold ‘System of Practice’ – Integration, Positive Emotion, Spiritual Death, and Spiritual Rebirth – as a framework for a psychology of spiritual transformation. I will not be getting into much detail on those four stages in this chapter – this is just an introductory preamble. In my subsequent chapters however, I shall provide a full explanation of each of the four stages, and my focus, as with much of my Buddhist writing, will be on the Dharmadhātu Mandala of the ten Buddhas (five male and five female) that we find in Tibetan Buddhist tradition. I want to show how Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’ may be viewed as a model that takes us on an ever-deepening spiritual journey into the meaning and transformative power of the archetypal principles that are symbolised in that mandala. I also want to show why that mandala is so important – such a valuable guide for the spiritual practitioner.

I use my understanding of the four-fold version of Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’ every day in my approach to meditation and in my approach to life, and I find it enormously valuable. I want to acknowledge at the outset however, that the understanding that I am presenting in this book is almost certainly a somewhat unorthodox one, and does not conform to any of the other interpretations that I have come across. While I hope that it will resonate with the experience of many, it certainly does not claim to represent the current consensus among Sangharakshita’s students in the Triratna Buddhist Community. Indeed, I am not aware if such a consensus exists – the model has been explained and elaborated in a variety of ways. So, please understand that I am merely sharing a perspective here – albeit with the conviction that I feel – in the hope that my readers will be stimulated to engage in their own experiential enquiry. As always, I am also trusting that my readers will apply their own discernment to anything I say.

 

In the course of the first millennium of the Buddhist tradition, a three-level model of mind evolved, which came to be called the Trikāya Doctrine. This model of the self presents the same perspective on the nature of spiritual development that Gautama Buddha had originally framed in terms of a Middle Way, but here it is presented as a more sophisticated and detailed conceptualisation.

In the Buddha’s original Middle Way teaching, he presents his spiritual path as a reconciliation of the seeming dichotomy of an unconditioned and eternal reality, with the conditioned and time-bound reality of our concrete world. In the trikāya, the unconditioned and eternal dimension is called the dharmakāya, and the conditioned and time-bound dimension is called the nirmānakāya. The path of reconciliation, or Middle Way, is presented to us in the trikāya as an intermediate level called the sambhogakāya, which over time, came to be represented symbolically by the mandala of the five, and subsequently ten, archetypal Buddhas. That archetypal mandala, often called the Dharmadhātu Mandala, is most comprehensively described in the Bardo Thodol texts (Tibetan Book of the Dead), which are ascribed to Padmasambhava, but its roots are to be found in several of Gautama Buddha’s teachings – especially his teachings on the ‘emptiness’, or non-personal nature, of the ancient Indian skandhas (which I shall be talking about in detail in a future chapter).

The Buddha’s ‘Four Noble Truths’ – a formulation that he presented shortly after his Enlightenment – is yet another conceptualisation that challenges us to transcend the dichotomy of the mundane and the eternal – a dichotomy that is resolved in both the Middle Way and in the trikāya doctrine. Here we see the Buddha presenting two pairs – one pair describing the suffering nirmānakāya world of conditioning and constraint, and the causal processes that sustain that suffering (i.e. dukkha and the causes of dukkha); and a second pair describing the possibility of liberation from that conditioning through a systematic engagement with the beneficent transcendental reality that became known as the dharmakāya. He spoke of this second pair in terms of nirvana: the extinction of the emotional momentum of the self-illusion by our coming to rest ‘as’ the dharmakāya; and the Dharmic path of transformation that leads to that realisation.

The Middle Way teaching is often characterised simply as an admonition to avoid the extremes of ‘nihilism’ and ‘eternalism’ that were current in ancient Indian spiritual thought of the Buddha’s time. We can see parallels in contemporary thought – the nihilism of the scientific materialist atheism, and the various forms of fundamentalist belief in an objectively existing God and an eternally existing personal soul, such as we find in Christianity. While the avoidance of these extremes may be a good place to start in our understanding, we need to be careful to not to end up avoiding the poles in this dichotomy to such an extent that we fail to engage with the reconciliation of the two fundamental realities of the mundane and the eternal.

Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’, provides a framework for just such a systematic engagement with the transcendental. It is an engagement that in my view is well characterised, not simply as a process that facilitates a transformative evolution of the body-mind, but as a process of coming into relationship with the benevolent objective and collective reality of the dharmakāya and its reflection in the visionary and bodily-felt world of the sambhogakāya. The dharmakāya is a reality that I often like to make more accessible by calling it by its most important associated characteristic – Consciousness. I shall be refining this conceptualisation, but provisionally I am proposing that that there is an explicitly non-personal quality of the dharmakāya that, for the sake of brevity, we can call Consciousness. This is the ’empty’ vijñāna skandha that the Buddha spoke of, and which is placed at the centre of the Buddhist mandala of cognition and perception. I like to speak of Consciousness in this way, and make this explicit connection between Consciousness and the dharmakāya, because we need to acknowledge that the apparently personal experience of human Consciousness – the crucial experience of being aware of being aware – is the most obviously unconditioned aspect of our experience, and is the means of our return to wholeness, and the source of our realisation.

Continue reading

January 4, 2024

Please click above to like the Facebook page associated with this site. To register for email notifications, please click the ‘Subscribe’ button below.

  • About William Roy Parker
  • About Mandala of Love
  • Contact William Roy Parker
  • Online Courses
  • Unsubscribe

Tags
#AppreciativeJoy #ArchetypalPsychology #Archetype #BardoThodol #Being #Brahmaviharas #Buddha #Buddhism #Buddhist #ByronBay #CarlJung #CGJung #Chakras #Compassion #Consciousness #Equanimity #Ethical #Ethics #FiveBuddhas #LovingKindness #Mandala #MandalaOfLove #Meditation #MentalBody #Metta #Mindfulness #NonDuality #NVC #Objectivity #Psychology #Psychotherapy #Qualia #QuantumMechanics #QuantumPhysics #SelfEnquiry #SelfInquiry #Shadow #Society #Soul #Spiritual #SubtleBodies #SympatheticJoy #TibetanBuddhism #WilliamRoyParker #Zen
Recently Published Articles
  • 4. Buddhism, Focusing and Mindfulness
  • 3. Buddhism, Focusing and the Brahmavihāras
  • 2. Buddhism, Focusing, and ‘Self-Discovery’
  • 4. Self-Power, Other-Power, and Beyond – Part 2
  • 3. Self-Power, Other-Power, and Beyond – Part 1
  • 2. The Trikāya Doctrine – A ‘Middle Way’ Model of Mind
  • Caitlin Johnstone on the Ukraine Proxy-War
  • ‘Mainstream Media’ and ‘Conspiracy Theories’ – some Buddhist thoughts
  • The Trikāya – The Sambhogakāya Mandala as the Middle Way
  • The Ten Archetypal Buddhas of the Mandala – Part 8: Māmaki
  • Why would Australia want to align with the US against China?
  • Buddha; Dharma; Sangha, and the Five Wisdoms Mandala – Preface
Archive
  • February 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • March 2024
  • January 2024
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • May 2023
  • June 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • December 2021
  • May 2021
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • October 2019
  • June 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
Enter a search term to search this site:-
Other Posts:
  • Art / Culture / History / Economics / Geopolitics / Anti-war
  • Anti-War
  • Economics
  • History
Recent Posts
  • 4. Buddhism, Focusing and Mindfulness
  • 3. Buddhism, Focusing and the Brahmavihāras
  • 2. Buddhism, Focusing, and ‘Self-Discovery’
  • 4. Self-Power, Other-Power, and Beyond – Part 2
  • 3. Self-Power, Other-Power, and Beyond – Part 1
Before you leave ……
  • Facebook – Mandala of Love
  • Mandala of Love Email Signup Page
Support This Site

If you like what I do, and find my writing useful, please consider donating via this Ko-fi link.

Donate
© William Roy Parker
Scroll to top
Loading Comments...