This is one the introductory chapters of a rather ambitious book that I am writing that is provisionally entitled ‘Mandala of Love – A Tantric Buddhist model of Mind and Meditation Practice’. In the previous chapter, which you can read here, I introduce two important Dharmic frameworks – the Trikāya Doctrine and Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’. I recommend that you read that chapter first. I find the trikāya to be a fundamental framework for understanding Buddhism, and find that it provides a useful doorway into an understanding of the Buddha’s notion of a Middle Way – an idea that we need to be able to understand deeply and broadly, as both a philosophical principle and an approach to practice.
I want to emphasise, as I did in my preface to the previous article, that the approach to understanding Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’ that I am offering here, is a very personal one – I might even say that it is a maverick view. While I may share my thoughts with some conviction, I am not asserting a definitive interpretation. I only want to contribute to the discussion.
This chapter is, in large part, a response to the powerfully explanatory ‘Three Myths’ model (‘self-development’, ‘self-surrender’ and ‘self-discovery’) that was presented by Sangharakshita’s student, Dharmachari Subhuti, in 2003. Not a ‘model’ as such, this is a conceptual framework that many who know the history of the Buddhist tradition will be familiar with. I find it very engaging because I believe that it illuminates important universal truths. Indeed, this conceptualisation – a fresh naming of the three main strands of philosophy and practice within the Buddhist tradition – presents Buddhism as containing three nested archetypal perspectives. Like many others, I have adapted the model to some extent, as I have made use of it to explain the way I have come to think about Dharma practice. Once again, my presentation of this conceptual framework should be regarded only as a personal view, and as a stimulus to reflection and discussion – and certainly not as definitive in any way.
This chapter contains a lot of reflections that may seem very personal to my particular process of learning within Buddhism, which was perhaps somewhat unusual. It does however contain a lot of challenging insights that seem to me to be universal and generally applicable. Although these understandings have been difficult to adequately articulate, they seem to me, when I look at what is currently happening in our world, to be extremely urgent and important. I welcome comments, if anyone wants to write to me via the contact form.
In this chapter, I shall be continuing to introduce the Trikāya Doctrine and Sangharakshita’s ‘System of Practice’. I shall also be making use of Dharmachari Subhuti’s ‘Three Myths’ model, which I introduced at the end of my last chapter, as a way of exploring the dichotomy of ‘self-power’ and ‘other-power’ in Dharma practice. In his ‘Three Myths’ talk (2003) and article (2004), Subhuti set out to draw our attention to the way Dharma practice, for Western practitioners, tends to progress in a way that begins with a ‘self-power’ emphasis (an archetypal perspective that has been called the ‘self-development’ myth); and then moves to incorporate an ‘other-power’ dimension (an archetypal perspective that has been called the ‘self-surrender’ myth); and then moves to an approach that transcends the apparent dichotomy of the two previous stages (an archetypal perspective that has been called the ‘self-discovery’ myth).
The ‘Three Myths’ framework gives us a way of understanding the three yānas – Hinayāna; Mahayāna; Vajrayāna – the three phases of the historical evolution of Buddhism. Even more significantly however, it shows us how the corresponding shifts of apparent emphasis within Buddhist philosophy are reflected in our own evolving practice. Following Subhuti’s archetypal approach to this enquiry, I also want to reflect further on the need for those of us who aspire to be more conscious, to gain a capacity for this sort of archetypal psychological reflection. By this, I do not mean only an awareness of the archetypal Buddhas of the sambhogakāya. We also need to be keenly aware of the corresponding ‘negative’ archetypal imagery of the Buddhist tradition’s ‘Six Realms’ – the archetypes that show us the egoic mind’s dysfunction. This is a theme that I shall be covering in more detail in later chapters. In this two-part essay, my focus shall be on an exploration of Subhuti’s three archetypal perspectives.
This three-fold archetypal analysis generates a vast amount of reflection for me. I have a lot of criticism to share in regard to the ‘self-development’ perspective – a perspective that becomes very problematic when it is practiced in isolation, especially if it also being practiced in an extreme way – and I shall be highlighting the great need for us to aspire to a three-fold synthesis of the three archetypal perspectives. The adoption, as our sole frame of reference for understanding Buddhism, of the philosophically narrow and one-sided ‘self-development’ view can be disastrous. Because the necessary Middle Way balance to the ‘self-development’ view is found in the ‘self-surrender’ view, we need to get experientially clear as to what that means. This is why I prefer to use the term ‘other-power’ in connection with the ‘self-surrender’ perspective. We need to be very clear what we are surrendering to. We need to be clear that we are surrendering to the objectively existing dharmic ‘other-power’ of the sambhogakāya and dharmakāya – not simply to a constructed ideal that the heroic ego has imagined, or to the authority of those who represent the Buddhist tradition.
Presenting a three-fold view that offers the potential for a reconciliation of the dichotomy of ‘self-power’ and ‘other-power’, I shall be offering a perspective on the Vajrayāna. Tibetan Vajrayāna is culturally extraordinarily rich and complex – so much so, that Western practitioners can sometimes miss what is most essential and most valuable in the tradition. Hopefully cutting through some of that cultural complexity, I shall be seeking that essence of Vajrayāna that was present, I believe, at various times, in Gautama Buddha’s teachings – most notably in his characterisation of his teaching as a ‘Middle Way’.
I shall be presenting Vajrayāna as a mode of practice that aspires to a transcendence of ‘self-power’ / ‘other-power’ dichotomy – a mode of practice that incorporates, but also transcends, both the heroic idealism of ‘self-power’ (the ‘self-development’ myth), and the devotional-receptive ‘other-power’ perspective (the ‘self-surrender’ myth). For me, the term ‘self-discovery’ does not begin to encompass the subtlety and profundity of the Vajrayāna perspective, but a conceptual label that would do it justice would be hard to find – so I hope that my provisional use of the term Vajrayāna for the three-fold view, will itself serve us as an adequate conceptual label. This third way, or Middle Way, that I am, perhaps rather confusingly, calling Vajrayāna, is found in every part of the Buddhist tradition. Wherever a true ‘other-power’ Buddhism is practiced, there exists the possibility of this experiential reconciliation of ‘self-power’ and ‘other-power’; of nirmānakāya and dharmakāya; of conditioned and unconditioned; and of samsara and nirvāna – and it is that reconciliatory view, and that reconciliatory approach to practice, that I am calling Vajrayāna.
The Buddhist path looks very different at the end than it does at the beginning. Indeed, it is common for Dharma practitioners to look back after decades of practice, and realise that their previous years of passionate engagement with the Dharma were informed by various egoic delusions – various misunderstandings or partial truths that had been constraining their progress. We may even realise that, in our idealistic striving, we were sometimes striving for the wrong things. We may become aware that we have created conflict for ourselves. We may even have to accept that we had, a times, put our trust in people who were ultimately not worthy of the degree of trust that we placed in them.
We may find that an un-discerning trust in the reliability of the guidance of our teachers is held up to us as a virtue. The Buddhas own teaching in this regard was in stark contrast. He urged us to regard all teachings, including his own (and interpretations of his own teachings) as provisional – as hypotheses to be tested in our experience. Every aspect of spiritual teaching, from our basic meditation practices and ethical precepts to the highest metaphysical teachings, must be subjected to this testing process. Indeed the spiritual life can be seen as a progressive process in which we gradually refine our understanding through the rigour of this testing process. The teaching frameworks of various strands of the Buddhist tradition are nirmānakāya phenomena – they are imperfect and provisional. It is only by deep contemplation and scrutiny, and by seeking to realise the sambhogakāya and dharmakāya realities behind the teachings, that we can discern the truth.
The whole Buddhist tradition has engaged in this testing and refinement process over the twenty-five centuries of its history. Indeed, it has been through several major ‘life-review processes’ collectively, and has sometimes recognised that its earlier conceptualisations were inadequate or incomplete. The Buddhist tradition’s development through three cultural and historical phases – Hinayāna, Mahayāna and Vajrayāna – may be seen both as a consequence of a natural self-critical and reflective process, and as a natural collective evolution in which the archetypal realities of the sambhogakāya and dharmakāya were being articulated more and more clearly over time in the concrete nirmānakāya world of the recorded Buddhist teachings and associated culture.
So, via processes that involved both rigorous introverted thinking and an ongoing conceptual clarification of the traditions teachings, on one side; and direct visionary revelation of the sambhogakāya level of mind, on the other, the tradition underwent a process of improvement and integration. These processes are now entering a whole new phase of consolidation, as centuries of traditional teachings are analysed by Westerners, and are becoming integrated with compatible currents within Western culture and Western psychological thought.